Bollywood shines spotlight on health disorders
The opening of a film
focusing on the rare Progeria disorder is the latest in a spate of
Bollywood films about health disorders. The BBC's Prachi Pinglay looks
at why the Indian film industry is departing from its traditional
formula to tackle weighty issues such as autism and Alzheimer's disease.
Still from Paa
Bollywood superstar Amitabh Bachchan plays a young boy with Progeria
Auro is 13, but looks 65. He has Progeria - a rare disorder which accelerates ageing in children.
Pia has been married to a man for over 20 years but she does not always remember him. She has Alzheimer's disease.
Ishaan, eight, is a gifted painter but messes up his numbers and letters. He is dyslexic.
Sanjay Singhania cannot remember how his wife was killed, yet he wants
to take revenge. He suffers from "short-term memory loss", a type of
amnesia developed after a traumatic incident.
What links these people?
They all have neurological conditions, and are the protagonists of mainstream Hindi films released in the last two years.
'Social change'
Bollywood has long been known for stories with predictable beginnings and endings.
But now filmmakers are exploring seemingly different plots with films
such as Taare Zameen Par (Stars on earth); U, Me Aur Hum (You, me and
us) and Apna Aasman (Our sky) over the last two years.
Still from U Me aur Hum
U, Me aur Hum dealt with the issue of Alzheimer's
The latest to join the list is Paa, which opened this weekend.
Bollywood's biggest-ever star Amitabh Bachchan plays a 13-year-old boy
with Progeria. His real-life son Abhishek Bachchan plays his father.
The reasons for making these films differ with each filmmaker.
Paa director R Balki says he wanted to make a film with Amitabh and Abhishek Bachchan and cast them in reversed roles.
"Once I saw Mr Bachchan joking with Abhishek, and Abhishek was behaving
in a mature way. That is when I decided to make a film with the roles
reversed. We consulted doctors and researched Progeria. The film is not
about Progeria but about father-son relationship," he said.
Amol Gupte, writer of Taare Zameen Par, said he made the film primarily "to take a re-look at parenting".
In the film, eight-year-old Ishaan is dyslexic, but a gifted painter.
However, he is always compared with his "normal" elder brother and goes
through several ups and downs before his talent is finally recognised.
Mr Gupte, who says he makes films for "social change and
sensitisation", maintains dyslexia is not a disability but a
neurological difference.
A feature film needs to entertain. This is not a medium for preaching. You have to connect with the audience
Director R Balki
"It is called the gift of dyslexia. Problems are not in children.
Problems are in the system. They are making patients out of children.
You cannot be whipping a child into 'ability'."
These films can be broadly divided into two types: Tug-at-your-heart
films where the underdog rises above the adverse situation, such as
Taare Zameen Par, and Iqbal which has a deaf and mute protagonist; and
thrillers such as Ghajini, where the protagonist has anterograde
amnesia, and Bhool Bhulaiya, which deals with multiple personality
disorder.
Most recently, super-hit Kaminey had the hero playing twin brothers - a
pet Bollywood formula, but in this case one with a lisp and the other
with a stammer.
More accepting
Trade analysts say audiences will accept a different film if it is entertaining.
Moreover, because of the growing number of multiplexes and the
corporatisation of the film industry in the last few years, several
production houses are producing cinema that is off-beat.
Sanjeev Lamba, CEO of Reliance Big Pictures which produced Paa, explains why they went ahead with financing the film.
"We think Paa is a wonderful, light-hearted family film at the core of
which is a very warm and loving father-son relationship. We believe
that audiences are rapidly building an affectionate relationship with
the central character Auro. While the story is about an unusual child
and a rare father-son relationship, the film is extremely entertaining
with emotional high points grounded within a loving family.
Still from Taare Zameen Par
Taare Zameen Par deals with dyslexia
"We have no doubt that audiences all over the world will embrace this story and its characters."
Though the stories may be different, most of these films have bankable,
popular mainstream stars like Aamir Khan, Kajol, Irrfan Khan and
Amitabh Bachchan.
Experts feel the Indian audiences are better informed now and hence more accepting of different themes.
Taran Adarsh, a well-known trade analyst, says: "Earlier people were
only aware of tuberculosis and cancer, but now people have access to
information.
"Also, filmmakers are getting more realistic. They are going beyond
"the revenge for father's death" and "the love triangle" formula.
"Audiences also want to know more. Even if the backdrop is different,
audiences can relate to it because they read about it. So if a film has
Progeria as the backdrop, it is fine. Because it is there, it exists."
As Amol Gupte says, "underdog overcoming difficulties" is the strongest
theme in world cinema and choosing a medical condition as the backdrop
is not uncommon to Western cinema.
More films are under production which have a central character with a certain medical condition.
For example, Bollywood superstar Shahrukh Khan is playing a man
suffering from Asperger's disease in an upcoming film, while Nana
Patekar is directing his son in a film with autism. Another untitled
film is based on a character who has a bipolar disorder.
Asked about the box-office performance of these films, director R Balki feels that as long as a film connects, it will work.
"A feature film needs to entertain. This is not a medium for preaching. You have to connect with the audience," he says.
-----------------------------------------------------------